A Biblical Look at Confession

Shaun McAfee

Shaun McAfee

Shaun McAfee is a veteran of the Air Force and current civilian in the Army Corps of Engineers as a Contract Specialist. He blogs at ShaunMcAfee.com. Currently he is pursuing a Masters in Dogmatic Theology with Holy Apostles College and Seminary where he also serves as the Social Media Director. He also works for Patrick Madrid's Envoy Institute as the Social Media Administrator. A convert to Catholicism, he loves learning, explaining, sharing, and defending the faith. He is married and has two boys named Gabriel and Tristan. They live in Omaha, NE.

Leave a Replay

33 thoughts on “A Biblical Look at Confession”

  1. Pingback: TUESDAY MORNING EDITION | iwannabeasaint

  2. The Church by its authority restricts formal Penance to going to a priest but it could in the future centuries change that if priests are scarce in say Siberia or Samoa etc.. It could return to James chapter 5 which urges people to “confess to one another” but it notes…to someone righteous like Elijah who may have been a Levite but also could have been from Benjamin or Gad according to Jewish traditions. In short James 5 doesn’t reference his origins but only his being righteous. What if there is both a priest shortage and a righteous person shortage say in Siberia or Samoa? What then? Then people will go to God directly and help the poor as penance per Isaiah wherein God will make your scarlet sins white as snow. But ordinarily right now by authority from God to the Church, if there are priests in your area, they are necessary excepting unusual situations like an abuse victim who trusts no priest in their very rural area…then epikeia obtains…the virtue whereby a person must omit the letter of the law while not omitting confession to God directly in their case.

    1. Unfortunately for your argument, the Church reserves some priestly functions to ordained priests alone: Confirmation, Extreme Unction (Sacrament of the Sick), Confession, and Holy Orders (by the bishop, whose station lives out the fullness of the priesthood).

      While the Church has established Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion to dispense the consecrated Body & Blood of Christ, She has NOT bestowed upon laity the authority to actually perform such Consecration – again, reserved exclusively to the ordained priesthood “in persona Christi.”

      Your suggestion denies the mind of the Church that the priest dispensing these Sacraments acts in the Person of Jesus Christ, reminding us that “I must decrease so that He may increase” is the application of “in persona Christi” to the Sacraments and to the Mass.

      The Church will permit laity to perform the Sacrament of Penance when She allows laity to consecrate the bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Jesus – right after She ordains teh first woman priest.

      Ain’t. Gonna. Happen.


      1. Actually John, since in a recent poll, over 40% of Catholics in Camden County N.J. said that Christ committed little sins while He was on earth, I suspect that the percentage of elderly Catholics especially going forward who know of spiritual Communion at all will be a small percent of Catholics…when in fact they all should know St. Alphonsus’ prayer and that being elderly in bed is no dimunition of sacramental life…not one iota as to the essence of Communion. If 1% know that, I’d be surprised…not 1% of Catholic avid readers but 1% of Catholics worldwide.

      2. Oh, that’s a shock to hear. There’s work to be done carrying the full message of hope to all. Excuse my presumption: I’m a recent convert, so I’ve had to study the Catechism recently. But isn’t it wonderful? Believe me, for I’d been happily Pentecostal for nearly 40 years: the Catholic Church is the real one!

      3. A black security guard from Holiness Church used to challenge my 16 years of Catholic education with Bible quotes and his knowledge forced me to read scripture…all of which I read in the ensuing years thanks to him and God who brought about the duel in the first place.

      4. Non-Catholics have access to fewer means of grace, I know that now for sure; but many make great use of what they have received. May God bless that dear security guard and bring him home – “keep the best wine till last”!

      5. How can you say the Catholic Church is more valid than any other one? What are the implications for non-Catholics?

    2. I like the idea of confessing my failings and wrongdoings. I do it with my good friends that I trust. They provide me with feedback.

      1. Are they righteous like Elijah which James 5 requires if you are proceeding by scripture only? Most modern friends can lack severity not about you but about the sin.

      2. Well I trust them more than anyone else and they know me very well. I have admitted many things of which I am ashamed.

        The problem I have in talking to priests and therapists is that they really don’t know you and can’t really give you any meaningful feedback.

      3. Shaun Alexander McAfee

        hat, hello.
        Are you Catholic? You’re right about trust; it’s uber important and equally difficult to confess if you are looking for mentoring alongside your forgiveness. Some go purely for the pardon, but it shows a more contrite heart to engage in advice/feedback/mentoring. I have a priest that knows me like a friend – so he is who I choose when possible. That’s an option if you can find a priest to be your regular confidant. God bless you my friend.

      4. I don’t see the point in asking for forgiveness unless you are trying to understand yourself and grow. Otherwise it just seems like you are begging to avoid ‘hell’.

      5. Shaun Alexander McAfee

        Yes, it’s the difference between “perfect contrition” and “imperfect contrition.” One wishes to be forgiven, is truly sorry, while also avoid sin and anything leading to sin. The less desirable state is where one only wishes to be forgiven simply for the fear of hell. You’re all over it, hat!

      6. I don’t even like the idea of asking for forgiveness. If I have wronged someone I would rather admit to what I have done and say I am sorry for the pain I have caused. If someone is truly sorry they won’t even ask for forgiveness.

      7. Shaun Alexander McAfee

        Don’t you see that sin is against God? You ARE admitting what you have done and saying sorry. That’s confession.

      8. I like all your testimonies on this touching issue, Hat. What you may be missing is the deep connection between forgiving others and being forgiven ourselves – Jesus said emphatically you can’t have the one without the other. And we need forgiveness, desperately. Not for some future insurance against Hell; but to be healed inside and changed now. The Catholic Sacrament of Penance – the confession and absolution thing – is a mystical grace conferred on His Church by our Lord which powerfully assists us to overcome sin and step into the joy and freedom of God’s children

      9. Even under those circumstances, the point as far as we are concerned is to achieve a change in ourselves – for that we can hope! Forgiving and asking forgiveness sets us free from guilt and shame. But to able to do so requires God’s help, and even then, time and patience and compassion toward ourselves.

      10. I hope you realize that confessing sins is not about getting feedback. It means you are really sorry for having done the evil did that you committed and are now resolved to do better.
        While feedback may be helpful, what happens at confession is the forgiveness of our sins.
        The confessional is not the psychiatrists chaise lounge.

      11. What do you need the priest for? Absolution. So that he can pass on to you God’s forgiveness as prescribed by Jesus Himself.

      12. True enough. Confession, Penance and Absolution are wonderful Sacraments – certain actions the Church does which God works through. I really know that, because I had 40 years of faith without them, and now they are making a huge difference in me. But we have to be real on this issue: out there are millions of Christians who are faithful without them, as I was, and many think a priest just gets in the way between them and God. In explaining Catholic teaching, we have to balance what we say about the Sacraments by acknowledging that God is Himself not at all limited by them. What I have now got free from is that rather abstract and reductive Protestant approach which dispenses with what it reasons is not essential. I now say “yes” to every channel He uses to give me grace, for every one of them is helpful for the changes He is doing in my body, soul and spirit.

  3. Unfortunately, the one point overlooked is almost all of Jesus’ healing dealt with
    first, forgiving the sin before a bodily cure could be realized. It was not unknown
    by the disciples and people living in the first century that sin was transferable to
    the next human life. The moist adroit example of this is when Jesus cured a man
    blind from birth. Whose sin they asked: his or the parents. Jesus did not feed into this indecent speculation while at the same time abstained from refuting an older understanding of a larger theological nature. When JP II put the statue of the Buddha on the altar at Assisi and met with the Dali Lama he was giving us a glimpse of another world dimension to this very notion of sin and forgiveness.

  4. Pingback: A Biblical Look at Confession »

  5. Pingback: Catholics and the “Extra Stuff” : IgnitumToday

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sign up for our Newsletter

Click edit button to change this text. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit