When the Rubber Hits the Road

Subtitle:

How NFP is really hard.

Let us return to the title of this post, and do not push aside the double entendre. Go there. For nothing says qu

ite what I am trying to say in this post like the title. It is a good feeling because rarely does a title in the blogosphere ever truly hit the nail on the proverbial head.

Before your mind goes totally in the gutter, let me help you back onto the way. For starters, proponents of NFP do a really bad job of shooting straight. The crookedness of the rhetoric is not so much a deception, but many times a naiveté born in the fires of the sales meeting. The salesman with the ketchup popsicle just cannot wait to tell the woman in the white gloves how much she will love the way the red accents her shoes. So too, the college freshman or couple who have never had to actually practice NFP will boast of its blissful benefits. I hear it is even under 500 calories.

I know. I”ve talked like that before.

Poetry is a problem as well. There is nothing wrong with the poetic quality of the Theology of the Body, but there is a problem with people thinking that life is always like poetry. Life is not like poetry, and we know that for the very reason we like poetry and that really great musical score behind Downton Abbey. No. Life is 5 degrees flat most of the time — an aching back, a sick child, a glass that is half empty no matter what you say. Look, dangit! That glass clearly has only 3 ounces in it. That is real life — and it is why poetry is an escape that points us the Place that is in tune.

Let me be clear. NFP is better than its alternative. The rubber really must hit the road, because nothing could more counterintuitive to the sexual embrace than wrapping yourself in cellophane or jamming chemicals down your throat. There is of course that really medieval thing-a-ma-jigger that places itself at the impasse between life and death — thwarting the possibility of children with the precision of an American gladiator with one of those . Seriously folks, there is nothing like finding out over an episode of your favorite sitcom that your contraception has been recalled and that you or someone you love is in danger of having “serious heart or health problems“.

Sheesh.

Going natural might be what is best for you, but it does not mean that it is what is easiest for you. That, of course, is the illusion of modernity. Ease is the measurement of morality, thus all manner of malady and mental discord go by the wayside in a quid pro quo movement that leaves society with — to steal a phrase from NBC — a really “new normal”, and the rest of us holding the crazy bag. Like the man with three ounces in his glass, modern man chooses a three ounce glass to make him feel his glass is all right. Self control and self restraint are difficult, even painful. But who needs that when my therapist tells me that both are a social construct.

Bye bye sin. Welcome to wacky land.

But you and I know there is sin. God — a Word beyond poetic capture — became flesh and dwelt among us. We beheld His glory and beat him, spit upon him, and crucified Him.

Not Easy

And kind of like that go around, NFP is difficult. It is hard. It is a Cross. The world is selling easy, and the Church — empowered by the Spirit that hovered over the void, bringing forth an almost infinitude of matter over the course of a long travail — is selling reality. The real. It is just beyond the grasp of psychoanalysis, just too difficult for the physicist to conceptualize. It is lying in a manger, and we are too busy trying to TiVo the last season of Madmen. Even technology doesn”t make it easy enough.

We can never get enough, and while the insatiable desire can point us to an infinite otherness, it can also speak to our stupidity. We are like men gathered around a newly formed pool after a summer rain, hoping that it will irrigate the cracked soil enough for a new crop. Yet just like the pool quickly evaporates, so too does everything that this world promises. We are not gnostics, I admit, but that does not mean we are hedonists. And if modern man struggles between two extremes it is those two — to be a bodiless ghost or a spiritless body.

I am a married father of five. We will have been married ten years this December. Our kids range from 6 years to 2 months. At this moment in our lives, trying to balance homeschooling, paying the bills, raising our kids in the faith, et. al., we feel God calling us to take a respite. We believe God wants us to steward what He has given us. That, of course, does not mean we are cutting ourselves off from life, but rather embracing that which we have been given. Either road is suffering, but only the road of obedience leads to salvation. That, salvation, is what God is selling, or rather offering — as a gift.

The point of this little quasi-essay is to encourage those who might read it to “be of good cheer”. The Servant who was rejected understands the burden of the Cross. You are not alone on this path. He asked you to take it up. That said, He promises that you will not receive more than you can handle. His grace is sufficient.

There are blogs out there dedicated to the way-cool-awesomeness of NFP. There are poems that have been written about the complementarity of the husband-wife union. There are songs and sonnets that could be produced lauding the transcendent beauty of jargon otherwise not known to those outside of certain cliques. That is not this blog post. This blog post is to remind all of us that God is calling us to a Cross — and for some it is marriage. The joy we are to have, the peace, is not because of the circumstances of the moment to which we are called — for it is truly a Moment.

What I mean is that all of us, young and old, single and married, come to a place in our lives where the proverbial rubber hits the proverbial road. Some less proverbial than others (cough, cough). The point, nevertheless, is that faith without works is dead — and that the Moment provides for us an opportunity to live that which we profess in the Creed. If God did come, if He is the Maker, and is planning on returning and all the rest, we might want to live like it. That is a sobering message, but it is the truth.

I know that I may have just rained on someone”s NFP-is-the-best-thing-since-pre-sliced-bagels parade, but never mind that. It rains on the just and unjust, so we should not be surprised. Rain is only terrible if you get caught in it unprepared. I hope this post helps some of you either in marriage or preparing for marriage to have an umbrella — because the rain is coming. That is reality.

Peace to you on your journey

Rich Text AreaToolbarBold (Ctrl B)Italic (Ctrl I)Strikethrough (Alt Shift D)Unordered list (Alt Shift U)Ordered list (Alt Shift O)Blockquote (Alt Shift Q)Align Left (Alt Shift L)Align Center (Alt Shift C)Align Right (Alt Shift R)Insert/edit link (Alt Shift A)Unlink (Alt Shift S)Insert More Tag (Alt Shift T)Proofread WritingToggle fullscreen mode (Alt Shift G)Show/Hide Kitchen Sink (Alt Shift Z)
FormatFormat▼
UnderlineAlign Full (Alt Shift J)Select text color▼
Paste as Plain TextPaste from WordRemove formattingInsert custom characterOutdentIndentUndo (Ctrl Z)Redo (Ctrl Y)Help (Alt Shift H)

Subtitle:
How NFP is really hard.
Let us return to the title of this post, and do not push aside the double entendre. Go there. For nothing says quite what I am trying to say in this post like the title. It is a good feeling because rarely does a title in the blogosphere ever truly hit the nail on the proverbial head.
Before your mind goes totally in the gutter, let me help you back onto the way. For starters, proponents of NFP do a really bad job of shooting straight. The crookedness of the rhetoric is not so much a deception, but many times a naiveté born in the fires of the sales meeting. The salesman with the ketchup popsicle just cannot wait to tell the woman in the white gloves how much she will love the way the red accents her shoes. So too, the college freshman or couple who have never had to actually practice NFP will boast of its blissful benefits. I hear it is even under 500 calories.
I know. I”ve talked like that before.
Poetry is a problem as well. There is nothing wrong with the poetic quality of the Theology of the Body, but there is a problem with people thinking that life is always like poetry. Life is not like poetry, and we know that for the very reason we like poetry and that really great musical score behind Downton Abbey. No. Life is 5 degrees flat most of the time — an aching back, a sick child, a glass that is half empty no matter what you say. Look, dangit! That glass clearly has only 3 ounces in it. That is real life — and it is why poetry is an escape that points us the Place that is in tune.
Let me be clear. NFP is better than its alternative. The rubber really must hit the road, because nothing could more counterintuitive to the sexual embrace than wrapping yourself in cellophane or jamming chemicals down your throat. There is of course that really medieval thing-a-ma-jigger that places itself at the impasse between life and death — thwarting the possibility of children with the precision of an American gladiator with one of those cue tip things. Seriously folks, there is nothing like finding out over an episode of your favorite sitcom that your contraception has been recalled and that you or someone you love is in danger of having “serious heart or health problems”.
Sheesh.
Going natural might be what is best for you, but it does not mean that it is what is easiest for you. That, of course, is the illusion of modernity. Ease is the measurement of morality, thus all manner of malady and mental discord go by the wayside in a quid pro quo movement that leaves society with — to steal a phrase from NBC — a really “new normal”, and the rest of us holding the crazy bag. Like the man with three ounces in his glass, modern man chooses a three ounce glass to make him feel his glass is all right. Self control and self restraint are difficult, even painful. But who needs that when my therapist tells me that both are a social construct.
Bye bye sin. Welcome to wacky land.
But you and I know there is sin. God — a Word beyond poetic capture — became flesh and dwelt among us. We beheld His glory and beat him, spit upon him, and crucified Him.

Not EasyAnd kind of like that go around, NFP is difficult. It is hard. It is a Cross. The world is selling easy, and the Church — empowered by the Spirit that hovered over the void, bringing forth an almost infinitude of matter over the course of a long travail — is selling reality. The real. It is just beyond the grasp of psychoanalysis, just too difficult for the physicist to conceptualize. It is lying in a manger, and we are too busy trying to TiVo the last season of Madmen. Even technology doesn”t make it easy enough.
We can never get enough, and while the insatiable desire can point us to an infinite otherness, it can also speak to our stupidity. We are like men gathered around a newly formed pool after a summer rain, hoping that it will irrigate the cracked soil enough for a new crop. Yet just like the pool quickly evaporates, so too does everything that this world promises. We are not gnostics, I admit, but that does not mean we are hedonists. And if modern man struggles between two extremes it is those two — to be a bodiless ghost or a spiritless body.
I am a married father of five. We will have been married ten years this December. Our kids range from 6 years to 2 months. At this moment in our lives, trying to balance homeschooling, paying the bills, raising our kids in the faith, et. al., we feel God calling us to take a respite. We believe God wants us to steward what He has given us. That, of course, does not mean we are cutting ourselves off from life, but rather embracing that which we have been given. Either road is suffering, but only the road of obedience leads to salvation. That, salvation, is what God is selling, or rather offering — as a gift.
The point of this little quasi-essay is to encourage those who might read it to “be of good cheer”. The Servant who was rejected understands the burden of the Cross. You are not alone on this path. He asked you to take it up. That said, He promises that you will not receive more than you can handle. His grace is sufficient.
There are blogs out there dedicated to the way-cool-awesomeness of NFP. There are poems that have been written about the complementarity of the husband-wife union. There are songs and sonnets that could be produced lauding the transcendent beauty of jargon otherwise not known to those outside of certain cliques. That is not this blog post. This blog post is to remind all of us that God is calling us to a Cross — and for some it is marriage. The joy we are to have, the peace, is not because of the circumstances of the moment to which we are called — for it is truly a Moment.
What I mean is that all of us, young and old, single and married, come to a place in our lives where the proverbial rubber hits the proverbial road. Some less proverbial than others (cough, cough). The point, nevertheless, is that faith without works is dead — and that the Moment provides for us an opportunity to live that which we profess in the Creed. If God did come, if He is the Maker, and is planning on returning and all the rest, we might want to live like it. That is a sobering message, but it is the truth.
I know that I may have just rained on someone”s NFP-is-the-best-thing-since-pre-sliced-bagels parade, but never mind that. It rains on the just and unjust, so we should not be surprised. Rain is only terrible if you get caught in it unprepared. I hope this post helps some of you either in marriage or preparing for marriage to have an umbrella — because the rain is coming. That is reality.
Peace to you on your journey

Path:

Brent Stubbs

Brent Stubbs

is a father of five (+ 1 in heaven), husband of one, convert, and a generally interested person. He has a BA in Theology, studied graduate philosophy, has an MBA, is a writer (or so he tells himself) and prefers his coffee black. His website is Almost Not Catholic. His Twitter handle is @2bcatholic. His favorite color is blue.

Leave a Replay

20 thoughts on “When the Rubber Hits the Road”

  1. Thank you for this post. The timing is somewhat amazing since I have been feeling slightly alone on this whole subject. My husband and I have been married 15 years, we have 7 children, homeschool, and we practice NFP, most of the time?! My children are 12, 11, 8, 6, 4, 2, and 8 months. I was beginning to think that most people don’t actually practice NFP because no one seems to truly “get it” and I am including the supporters. It is a cross for sure and truly humbling. My husband got his Masters in theology as well and I thought this might help him deal with this cross even more, however, it hasn’t. It is a struggle and one I am willing to continue to fight for. Nothing compares to the actual cross of Christ, so why am I complaining? I am comforted by your post and I feel reassured that it is not suppose to be easy. Even after being up most of the night, I will be smiling all day. At least most of the day!! GOD BLESS!

  2. Dub Lord of the Sith

    NFP sucks.
    I am a father of 5 as well. We homeschool. We practice NFP rarely, if only because my wife is always pregnant (Catholic birth control= wife is pregnant). But now that our family size seems to be leveling off, and we actually have to start ACTUALLY DOING nfp more often, I can’t stand it. I realize what a weak and selfish pile of flesh I am.
    Honestly, I want to know if castration is a mortal sin for a Catholic (I am not kidding). Cus if it is only venial, I will go for it.
    I love my wife, but I get tired of having this physical desire constantly control my brain like an animal. It truly is a cross.

    1. Maybe your intense suffering is a sign that you shouldn’t be doing NFP. Are you sure that desiring the marital embrace is selfish? Isn’t it, rather, mutual self-giving? Sometimes, when both spouses don’t agree to NFP but do it anyway, it really becomes unilateral self-denial by one of the spouses. Will your wife suffer serious health problems if she becomes pregnant? Will your family go into the poorhouse with one more child? These are not rhetorical questions.

    2. Dub, anti-depressants are a great …hum…appetite suppressant. My husband takes them so I know from experience. They have a side effect of making you happy-(ier) hence making the whole family happy. And I’m sure the Church has no official stand on that (yet 😉

  3. Dub Lord of the Sith

    I forgot to mention:
    I love what you said about the unintended deception that takes place with NFP proponents.
    Almost every time I hear NFP talked about, it is just put out there as an option with no qualifiers.

    But folks: You can be using NFP and sinning quite easily, and I think many, many Catholics do so. It cant just be used for any reason. You must have a good reason. It can be used for the same reasons as the pill is used. And most of our culture is not using the pill for good reasons! Think of all the 2 kid families with mom on the pill or dad has a vesectomy. Their reasons are nearly always horribly selfish. And I think that we Catholics can easily use NFP for these same reasons.

    This is also part of the dark side of NFP.

  4. I’ve read a lot of “NFP is awesome!” posts.

    I’ve read a lot of “NFP super sucks!” posts.

    What I rarely see is “why NFP can super suck and how to make it suck less, and perhaps even be awesome.”

    I’ve had experience with both and I’ve blogged about what made the difference.

    And this is the problem I have with this post. There is no hope. No advice. Just suffering to satisfy who seems to be a harsh and angry God.

    Put another way, the Church teaches that “sexuality is a source of joy and pleasure in a marriage”. CCC 2362. If sexuality is a cross in your marriage, that isn’t what God wants. Don’t just suffer, get help!

    1. There is hope. His name is Jesus. Disordered sexuality is a source of frustration. A lot of things are meant for pleasure and joy, but Christ asked us at times to suffer. Sin may seem pleasurable — even joyous, but it is a vacuous promise. That is the point of this post. I recommend you read it again, especially the last paragraph.

      Peace to you.

  5. My wife & I have been practicing NFP for 12 years with 3 children in-between. We married later in life than average (early 30’s), so I spent many years trying live a chaste life as a single man. With that experience, going “without” during a certain portion of a fertility cycle is really no big deal (for me). I think it relates to appetites. The more food you eat, the more your appetite increases, the more you will suffer with less food.

  6. Sexuality is a gift and children are a blessing. Anything we do to prevent or stop either is an attempt to thwart God’s goodness toward us.

    My family is not Catholic, Lutheran actually. We have five children ( +1 in heaven…ages 9 to 6months ) and do nothing to *prevent* children in our marriage and to this point in our lives, we see no reason to *prevent* to two of us from from being together and enjoying one another ( if you know what I mean…wink wink, nod nod…didn’t know how to word this 😀 ).

    And I pray there are no health issues in our future where we might be confronted with such a decision. We have known couples here and there who have this dilemma.

    We feel there is so much freedom in living this way. My two cents. Enjoyed the old blog and updated my blog reader to this site so I can continue following.

  7. Our hope is Jesus.

    My point is that if NFP sucks, there is often a reason WHY it sucks, and dealing with these reasons can make it suck less.

    Our suffering does have a purpose, and with NFP, the suffering shows us the problems in our relationship, in ourselves, and sometimes with her health. The purpose is to alert us to these problems so that with God’s help, we can fix them.

    Talking about suffering without talking about solutions gives a distorted picture of marriage and of God.

    1. There is no solution to suffering. That assumes that suffering must be “solved” — which is a modern problem (see Descartes). Suffering is Christ’s invitation to join Him on the cross, so that we might also share in His glory.

      If you think I’ve distorted something, maybe be more specific.

      In reality, I think we agree with each other. My point is that even in a good marriage — where everything is great — there will be suffering. Some is self-induced, and working on those issues is a good thing (I agree!) Nevertheless, suffering is a part of the Christian walk, and that is okay. Marriage is a sacrament, an instrument of grace. Thus, it does not escape the Way of the Cross. Marriage is our opportunity to die to ourselves for the other.

      Also, see Sue’s comment above.

  8. Then perhaps I have misunderstood you.

    Suffering is indeed a part of life, including a part of marriage.

    No, we will never completely escape suffering. But some suffering is due to specific solvable problems.

    My problem is that the article doesn’t seem to recognize that many of the problems couples have with NFP are indeed solvable. And the Christian answer is to help people in this situation find solutions.

    Or as St. James put it:

    15 If a brother or sister has nothing to wear and has no food for the day,

    16 and one of you says to them, “Go in peace, keep warm, and eat well,” but you do not give them the necessities of the body, what good is it?

    James 2:15-16

    1. That is not what I said. I said “be of good cheer”. I reminded couples that Christ is with them in their suffering. The article certainly wasn’t exhaustive, so if you have something you would like to add, ever do pipe up!

      God bless, friend.

  9. NFP can suck, yes. What also sucks is when you’re one of those “special” women for whom NFP is largely unhelpful for tracking fertility. Talk about a cross! We must be overly-open to life, if you know what I mean. It’s a serious challenge of faith.

  10. Wow! for someone warning us that NFP isn’t poetry, you’re extremely poetic. but then perhaps NFP is more like The Wasteland or The Idyls of the King or, even more difficult, Le Morte D’Arthur.

    I’m neither a glass half full nor glass half empty kind of person. my concern is rather, am I thirsty? if so, does this glass contain something good to drink? if not, who cares how much it contains. this piece made me wonder for the first time, what if I’m thirsty & the glass contains something delicious but it doesn’t have enough to quench my thirst. I always imagined a 12 oz glass, never a six oz. my immediate response is that I’d ask God for more & trust Him to provide it. but I could feel really thirsty, it could go past the edge
    before more was provided. it has in the past & may again though I never imagined it in advance before.

    I’ll keep you & your wife in my prayers that not only will there be something delicious in the glass, but that you’ll have the strength to endure when refills aren’t quickly forthcoming. happy to have found your blog again. it’s worth the trip.

  11. I love this post. It was real. Honest. Not sugar coated, everything with Jesus is super-great-like-all-time. Reality.

    All my life I have wanted to be a man. I think it is a man’s world.

    One day, God enlightened me. “Would you want to have the monster of sexual desire on your back ALL THE TIME?” That is a difficult cross for a man to carry. That is why you all are so strong. I don’t understand you guys, but I admire you.

  12. *”I hope this post helps some of you either in marriage or preparing for marriage to have an umbrella — because the rain is coming.”*
    I’m glad you used the word ‘umbrella’ here rather than ‘raincoat’!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sign up for our Newsletter

Click edit button to change this text. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit